Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Atiba Shaikh's avatar

As promised, here are my thoughts on this:

1. The reason proper channels are important is because people take them a lot more seriously than social media (no matter how many dead people they see on the feed people keep saying they are fake). For a while I hoped against hoped that social media would be some good here but in a few months it was clear it won’t be)

2. Humans are not meant to see things like these at all and definitely not on a 24/7 cycle which is why these images are blurred when they appear on news

3. Raising awareness can be done without resorting to this as well

4. Like you said, these images usually only circulate within one’s individual bubble

5. One day, people will be against this regardless of whether these images were shared. In fact it is the title of the book by Omar El Akkad called One Day Everyone Will Have Always Been Against This

All in all, I think people arguing about raising awareness sounds somewhat similar to something similar a few years back regarding staying in the know via news. People are offended whenever they see someone who says they stopped watching the news because of the negativity, but I did something similar. Because watching the news wasn’t helping me to take action and wasn’t showing anything new to me beyond the first few headlines. If anything it causes us to get into inaction because reading the news itself can be felt as taking action or seeing the negativity (and in this case, dead bodies) can paralyse us from further action.

Lastly, I feel it is tragic that the Palestinians in their innocence thought that this will change the world’s mind which it unfortunately wouldn’t.

Expand full comment
Waheedah Shaheed's avatar

Jews have not spent as much time in the past 90 years sharing images of their suffering as Muslims have in the past six months of ours. This is only a slight exaggeration.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts